Making these biscuits (OK then, go ahead and call them cookies, if you must) reminded me of a long-held grudge.
Many moons ago, way back when I was a young teenager, I had a home economics teacher who we’ll call Mrs. X.
Now I don’t know whether you have these kinds of classes in your country, but let me tell you, they were a welcome distraction from the daily drudge of Maths, English and so on … and hence looked forward to for days. You would be given a list of ingredients the week before, you’d go off and do your shopping with your mum, carefully pack said ingredients into a wicker basket with a gingham cover over it (it had to have the gingham cover) and then on ‘the day of’ you’d excitedly carry them to school with you to make your cake, or lasagne, or biscuits, or scones, or whatever it was you’d been told you were making that day.
This one particular time we were going to make a Christmas cake. I remember being extra excited about that. I guess even at that age it gave me a bit of a warm fuzzy feeling to know that others might get to enjoy something I’d cooked or baked. So you can imagine my disappointment when we cut into my cake on Christmas Day (after oh-so-carefully icing it, I might add) and the middle immediately started to run and dribble its way out to the edge of the plate, like some cake version of a mudslide laden with currants and raisins and cherries and brandy and mixed peel and mixed nuts and spices and whatever other ingredients that you generally stuff into a typical Christmas cake. And all this after Mrs. X had insisted that my cake was done and ready to take out of the oven, coincidentally (?) just before the bell for the end of the lesson was about to ring. Even to my untrained eye it still looked a little too pale and wobbly in the middle, but out it came. She didn’t give me any other choice.
Needless to say, I (and my mum who had spent a pretty penny on the ingredients) were more than a little bit miffed.
And am I really admitting that I’m still a little bit annoyed about this? Oops, I think I am. I’m usually such a forgiving soul as well. But anyway, luckily for Mrs. X, I can’t remember her name so she’s safe from being named and shamed at least.
Besides, since then I too have spent a stint working as a teacher and I’m now pretty convinced it’s the world’s most challenging job. At times at least. And so I’d be willing to bet that probably somewhere out there in the world some poor now-grown-up teenager is holding a similar sort of grudge against me. I guess that would serve me right. I’m sorry, unknown teenager(s) who I unwittingly offended, wherever you are in the world.
And Mrs. X … if you ever come across this post, all is forgiven. Erm, well almost. Grrrr.
Another better (not to mention much earlier) memory of school economics lessons is the one where I got to make some Shrewsbury biscuits. Now I don’t think I can go any further without explaining a few things about these biscuits. They’re basically a very simple shortbread-y type of cookie (aka biscuit) with the optional addition of various flavourings such as rosewater, caraway seeds, nutmeg, cinnamon, citrus and vanilla. Apparently (according to Mr. Google), they date way way back to as early as the 1500s. Which I find a little bit hard to get my head around. How on earth can we still be eating these things six (SIX!) centuries later? Oh, and the original commercial recipe is said to have originated from the town of Shrewsbury in England in the 17th century. Hence the name.
And another thing about these biscuits. Pretty much every child in the history of Britain (probably starting in the 1500s) has to make them in their home ec class. In one of their very first classes, in fact. Yes, they’re that easy.
Literally, all you do to make these little beauties is cream together butter and sugar, stir in egg yolks, flour and lemon zest (and orange zest, if you like – I made this part up but it seemed to work), gather up into a ball, chill for a little while then roll out, cut out and bake. Done.
As it’s Easter this week and all that, I decided to use a flower-shaped cutter to cut my cookies out, ice them with a little icing sugar and lemon juice and finally sprinkle them with pastel-coloured full-of-the-joys-of-spring sprinkles. Preeee-teeee! The biscuits end up crispy around the edges but with a lovely soft-ish interior. Very much like shortbread but perhaps a little lighter. Perfect with a proper English cup of tea if I may say so!
OK, so just before I go, it’s confession time. Here goes: ‘I’m Helen and I’ve never made a proper American cookie.’ There, I said it.
But I reckon making these lovely simple and perfectly Easter-worthy citrusy biscuits was a great way to start working up to it.
Which leads me onto this. I need your advice. In your opinion, what American cookie should I have a go at first? Chocolate chip? Double chocolate? Triple chocolate banana brown butter pecan caramel s’mores swirl? 😉 (note that chocolate isn’t really optional) What recipe should I use? What’s your top cookie-making tip?
Hope you can help me. And finally … Kalo Pasxa! (Happy Easter in Greek)
Iced citrus Shrewsbury biscuits
Ingredients
For the biscuits
- 8 tablespoons butter left out of the fridge for a while to soften
- 2/3 cup sugar
- 2 egg yolks lightly whisked
- 1 cup flour
- zest of 2 lemons & 1 orange
For the icing
- 1 cup icing sugar
- a few squeezes of lemon juice
Instructions
-
Preheat the oven to 350F/180C and grease two baking sheets.
-
Cream the butter and sugar together either by hand with a wooden spoon or with a hand-held whisk until pale and fluffy.
-
Stir in the eggs, then the flour and citrus zest with the blade of an eating knife until it’s lumpy and all roughly worked in. Then gather the mixture up into a stiff dough with your hands. Wrap in plastic wrap and chill for at least half an hour.
-
Roll the dough out to a thickness of 4-5mm on a floured surface.
-
Cut out your biscuits with your chosen cutter, then place them on your baking tray and bake for about 15 minutes or until the biscuits have browned lightly.
-
Let the biscuits cool on a wire rack.
-
In the meantime, make the icing. Add a couple of squeezes of lemon to your icing sugar or until your icing is of the desired consistency.
-
Drop 1/2-teaspoons-full of icing into the centre of each biscuit and carefully spread out a little. Don’t put too much on as it easily runs over the edge of the biscuit.
-
Quickly sprinkle over your coloured sprinkles. Leave to set. Store in an airtight container if not eating immediately.
Recipe Notes
I kept my biscuits very simple, but if you like, you can experiment by replacing/adding to the citrus zest with 2 ounces/60 grams currants or raisins, ½ a teaspoon of caraway seeds, ½ a teaspoon of cinnamon, 2 teaspoons of rosewater or ¼ teaspoon of nutmeg … or a combination of these flavours.
My dough came together really easily, but if yours doesn’t, just add a tablespoon or so of milk.
You could replace the icing with a little melted chocolate (white, milk or dark!)
I hope you enjoyed this post! You can subscribe to receive posts directly to your inbox by entering your email address in the box below or at the top of the sidebar on the right.
You can also find more from Scrummy Lane on Facebook, Pinterest and Twitter and follow me on Bloglovin! Thanks so much for reading!
cupcake girl says
18 Apr 14 at 12:08 amOh these look yum +very cute. You have my sympathy-… myb your xmas cake trauma made you a better baker for it?!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 12:15 amHello and thanks so much for paying me a visit! So glad you like my biccies. I think that incident probably did make me a better baker, come to think of it. I’ll never undercook a Christmas cake again! Well, I hope. Happy Easter!
Lilli @ Sugar and Cinnamon says
18 Apr 14 at 1:32 amWhat cute biscuits! I love the sprinkle toppings 🙂
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:53 amThank you, Lilli, and Happy Easter! 🙂
Pamela @ Brooklyn Farm Girl says
18 Apr 14 at 3:46 amI’d eat more than my share of these biscuits. Love how they look too, extra pretty!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:49 amThanks, Pamela, and Happy Easter!
Mary Frances @ The Sweet Tooth Life says
18 Apr 14 at 7:04 amYour poor cake! Haha, I’m a notorious grudge holder too … It doesn’t bug me until I start taking about it. These cookies, biscuits, whatever look amazing! I’ve honestly never heard of anything like them, but new recipes are my favorite! Thanks for sharing Helen!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:39 amYou’re welcome, Mary Frances! I wondered at one point if these were too simple to share, but then again how can a classic be too simple? 🙂
Alyssa @ My Sequined Life says
18 Apr 14 at 8:08 amI wish I had one (or three…) of these cookies/biscuits as I type! Citrus is such a wonderful flavor for cookies, and the icing is so lovely! I tend to hold grudges, too, though I’m trying to work on letting things go. I can only imagine your disappointment with your Christmas cake! Geez. I bet these cookies certainly do not disappoint. 🙂
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 9:40 amSo glad you like the biscuits, Alyssa! Actually, I don’t usually hold grudges. This somehow just stuck in my memory for EVER! Happy Easter!
Norma | Allspice and Nutmeg says
18 Apr 14 at 3:09 pmThese biscuits look so cute. Great for Easter. I would start with chocolate chip cookies. They’re an all American favorite, easy to make and so so good.
I have a bit of a grudge against my 7th grade home Economics teacher. Ha! I understand how you feel.
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:32 pmHehe … so glad I’m not the only one!! 🙂
I think it has to be a choc chip cookie that I try first. It’s two votes for those so far!
Mademoiselle Gourmande says
18 Apr 14 at 3:34 pmThey look great! So easterish… 🙂 I love spring time! Thank you for sharing!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:31 pmThank you so much for passing by! And so glad you like the biscuits. I love springtime too!
Melanie @ Carmel Moments says
18 Apr 14 at 4:02 pmCute cookies. I mean biscuits. I mean… 🙂
I’m sure they taste fabulous regardless of what we call them. Love the citrus!
Have a GOOD Friday Helen!
He arose!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:30 pmThank you, Melanie! Actually, that’s what the Greeks say on Easter Sunday. They say ‘Christos Anesti’ which means Christ has risen, and you reply ‘Alithos anesti’ which means he has risen indeed. 🙂
shashi @ runninsrilankan says
18 Apr 14 at 4:31 pmYum – lemon and orange zest must make these cookies smell incredible – I swear I can smell them from here in Atlanta! 🙂
I think you should definitely try your hand at a chocolate chip cookie or skillet chocolate chip cookie – I haven’t tried this tip yet, but Sally @ Sally’s baking addiction mentioned using a little bit of cornstarch and brown sugar. Happy Easter Helen!!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 7:29 pmHappy Easter to you too, Shashi! And thanks so much for the tips! I’m definitely leaning towards trying a choc chip cookie first. It’s a classic after all. And as for the cornstarch tip, if Sally recommends it then I’m sure it’s a good tip! Thanks so much! 🙂
Ashley @ My Midwest Table says
18 Apr 14 at 7:49 pmI don’t care if they’re called biscuits or cookies, I’ll call them delicious! I love shortbread and citrus, and the flower shapes are so pretty.
I think you need to start with chocolate chip cookies. Classic. 🙂 Every time I make cookies, I end up freezing extra in the form of dough balls. That way, when a craving for milk and cookies hits in the evening, I’m only 15 minutes (7 to thaw on a baking sheet, 8 to bake) away from a happy belly!
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 9:18 pmThanks so much for the recommendation, Ashley … and late-night craving tips = super important. Chocolate chip cookies it is then! Oh no, that means I really have to do this. Scary! (well, just a little)
Natalie @ Tastes Lovely says
18 Apr 14 at 8:47 pmOh you poor thing! I hope your cake fiasco didn’t spoil baking for you for too long. Sorry, but I definitely had a good giggle at your story. I can just picture you cutting into your cake and raw batter running out.
These biscuits look delicious! Love the flower shape : )
Helen says
18 Apr 14 at 9:16 pmYeah, I guess it is quite funny … in retrospect. At the time though (age 11 or 12) you would have seen big fat disappointment on my face!
Glad you like the biccies! 🙂
cheri says
18 Apr 14 at 9:57 pmWhat cute little biscuit cookies, they are just perfect for this time of year looking all springy and all. Love recipes with stories and this is quite a good one Helen! Ha! Anyway, oatmeal chocolate chip or chocolate chip and some kind of nut would be a good place to start, can’t go wrong with either. Happy Easter!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 7:38 amThank you, lovely Cheri, and Happy Easter to you, too! I love how you call them ‘biscuit cookies’ … that’s very diplomatic of you! 😉
I think I definitely have to try making a chocolate chip cookie, first. Thanks for the suggestion!
Ashley says
18 Apr 14 at 10:39 pmI never got to take any classes like that in school! I did take an art class but that was about it! And these biscuits look delicious – I love all the citrus zest in them! Have a wonderful weekend lady!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 7:27 amReally? In Britain everyone has a cooking class … or at least they did when I was at school. It taught me everything I know … haha! Not really, but it was fun. Glad you like the biccies and … Happy Easter!
Aimee / WallflowerGirl.co.uk says
19 Apr 14 at 3:04 amThanks for the nostalgia! I used to love Home economics but remember being disappointed with any failures even back then. I think when you love doing something, and you know you’re quite good at it – and one of the few times you get to prove that goes wrong, it becomes more of a big deal than it would usually seem. Anyway, these are just adorable! And it was such a bad idea for me to come on here at 1am because now I have cravings for biscuits that I can’t have 🙁
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 7:24 amSorry about the craving, Aimee! That’s the only bad thing about reading food blogs late at night/early morning/actually any time at all … I get so hungry!
Glad you enjoyed the Home Ec memories. I’m not sure if I was good at it but I know I really enjoyed it. Have a great Easter weekend!
Liz says
19 Apr 14 at 4:16 amBeautiful spring-time biscuits! Perfect for the Easter buffet!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 7:21 amThank you, Liz. Happy Easter!
Liz says
19 Apr 14 at 4:23 amPS…YES, I’ve been in the same book club for 17 years. My youngest was 3 when we started…and now he’s a college sophomore! Makes me feel OLD 🙂
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 7:21 amNo, no, no, of course you’re not old! But that is amazing being in a book club for so long. Now I know who to come to when I need a book recommendation!
whatjessicabakednext says
19 Apr 14 at 10:08 amThese look amazing, Helen!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 10:51 amThanks, Jessica! 🙂
Eva says
19 Apr 14 at 1:45 pmTes biscuits sont extra! Mr.X doit être fier de toi!! Je veux manger aussi!! Bis
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 3:45 pmMerci beaucoup, Eva, et joyeuses Paques!! 🙂
Joanne says
19 Apr 14 at 3:04 pmWe didn’t get to take home ec in NYC schools, and I definitely feel like I missed out! I’ve never heard of these Shrewsbury biscuits, but you’ve made them so adorable!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 3:44 pmOh, OK! In Britain all kids get to have some cooking lessons … I think that’s still the case now then. So glad you like the biccies and … Happy Easter!
Consuelo @ Honey & Figs says
19 Apr 14 at 5:04 pmNope, we don’t have those home economics classes here (sadly!), but they sound super fun. Sorry about your cake though :'(
These biscuits look spectacular and your pictures are truly gorgeous! xx
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 5:09 pmCan’t believe you guys don’t have those classes! So glad you like my biscuits, though. Happy Easter, Consuelo!
Skye says
19 Apr 14 at 8:32 pmThese are so pretty – I love the little flower shape and the sprinkles. Gorgeous. And I love the ides of flavouring them with rosewater – I just have to make Shrewsbury biscuits too now.
For what it’s worth, I think that you should go for triple chocolate cookies – my favourite – a chocolate cookie with dark, milk and white chocolate chunks.
Happy Easter, Helen! Xx
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 11:30 pmThank you for the tip, Skye! I love the idea of the triple chocolate cookies … especially with the white chocolate chunks. I’d like to try the Shrewsbury biccies with rosewater, too. 🙂
sue/the view from great island says
19 Apr 14 at 10:44 pmI love these Helen! I can’t believe how historic the recipe is, and believe me, American cookies are overrated— they can’t possibly live up to something that’s lasted 5 centuries. And all I remember making in Home Ec is drawstring sneaker bag embroidered with my name, talk about useless!
Helen says
19 Apr 14 at 11:28 pmHahaha! Well, Sue, the Shrewsbury biscuit-making class might have been interesting and useful, but I do remember making my fair share of useless things in Home Ec, too. Let me think … a ‘needle case’ (but then again I think my mum does still use this), a patchwork cushion cover that took about two years to finish by hand which hasn’t lived to tell the tale and some bizarre contraption to tell the milk delivery man (we called him the milkman) how many bottles of milk to leave! That one definitely didn’t live to tell the tale!
Happy Easter! 🙂
Cate @ Chez CateyLou says
21 Apr 14 at 1:19 amThese biscuits / cookies look lovely! The flavor sounds great, and I love the cute sprinkles! And wow – never made a proper American cookie?? Chocolate Chip should definitely be your first!!!! I have quite a few recipes on my site if you are looking for variations 🙂
Helen says
21 Apr 14 at 7:25 amSo glad you like them, Cate … and thanks for the recommendation. The consensus is definitely chocolate chip … I’d love to check out your recipes! One thing is for sure, when I finally get around to it I’m going to have plenty of help!
Lorraine @ Not Quite Nigella says
21 Apr 14 at 4:15 amI’d be a bit cross about that too. After all you had to shop for the ingredients -we never did which probably explained why we had such boring food made in Home Ec!
Helen says
21 Apr 14 at 7:22 amHa! Glad someone else thinks I should have been annoyed 🙂
Allie | Baking a Moment says
22 Apr 14 at 12:56 amI had never heard of Shrewsbury biscuits before, so this was a really fun post to read! I think your biscuits came out so adorable. Love the flavors and the way you’ve decorated them. Good luck with the cookies, I’m sure you’ll have no shortage of fabulous (chocolate) recipes to pick from!
Helen says
22 Apr 14 at 7:38 amSo glad that you enjoyed this, Allie. It felt like going back to my childhood again decorating the biscuits! Thanks for the good wishes for the cookie-making, too. I think I definitely have to give it a go pretty soon now that I’ve told everyone about it! 😉
Chrissy says
22 Apr 14 at 6:27 amThese are adorable and perfect for Easter! I’d start with chocolate chip. Or peanut butter.
Helen says
22 Apr 14 at 7:24 amMaybe chocolate chip peanut butter? Thanks, Chrissy!
Chris @ Shared Appetite says
22 Apr 14 at 7:42 pmWhat beautiful biscuits… err, cookies… err, biscuits. Whatever you all them, they look delicious! And wow, I didn’t know they date back to the 1500s! So cool. And that story about Mrs. X… so funny!
Helen says
23 Apr 14 at 8:32 amHehe … glad I made you giggle, Chris. I didn’t know the biccies dated back that far, either. Cool, indeed!